top of page

Here are all the comments from the reviewers and our replies.

All of the information are public, and can be found on the website of this paper.

Reviewer 1

Anonymous

Round 1 (positive)

Reviewer 2

Anonymous

Round 1 (negative)

Round 2 (negative)

Round 3 (negative)

Appeal

Reviewer 3

Paolo Grigolini

Round 1 (positive)

Reviewer 4

Cyril S. Aslanov

Round 1 (positive)

Round 2 (positive)

Reviewer 5

Teodor Buchner

Round 1 (negative)

Round 2 (positive)

bottom of page